<% IssueDate = "11/19/02" IssueCategory = "Events" %> GayToday.com - Top Story
Top Story
Discharging Gay Arabic Linguists is Causing National Uproar

U.S. Army's Defense Language Institute under Intensified Fire

U.S. Has Shortage of Personnel to Translate Terrorist Threats

Compiled By GayToday
Servicemembers Legal Defense Network

Washington, D.C. -- Last week's report that the Army's Defense Language Institute (DLI) in Monterey, California has discharged ten linguists, including seven trained in the Arabic language, because of those service members' sexual orientation, has elicited strong criticism from members of Congress, the media, and the American public.

Representative Barney Frank (D-Massachusetts) said:

"For those who needed further evidence of how ill-advised the anti-gay military policy is, they now have it. Firing talented people who possess a scarce and sorely needed skill because some people don't like their choice of social companions puts prejudice ahead of national security."

Alfie Khalil, president of the American Federation of Government Employees Local 1263, which represents civilian employees at the Defense Language Institute, told the Monterey Herald that "we're sorry to lose the students."
Rep. Barney Frank: 'For those who needed further evidence of how ill-advised the anti-gay military policy is, they now have it'

The firings, which received national attention in the Associated Press, New York Times, Washington Post, USA Today and San Francisco Chronicle, among others, took place over a two month period from mid-August through mid-October 2002. An editorial appearing in Saturday's Newark Times-Ledger noted, in part, that "the incident once again illustrates the foolishness of the 'don't ask, don't tell' policy."

According to Don Hamilton, a staff member of the National Commission on Terrorism, Arabic is one of the most difficult languages to learn. The commission produced a report two years ago describing a "very severe" shortage of translators, and Hamilton said it can take two years to become even modestly proficient in Arabic.

"The American people have every right to be concerned about these firings," said C. Dixon Osburn, Executive Director of Servicemembers Legal Defense Network (SLDN), a legal aid and advocacy organization that assisted the linguists. "Our armed forces should never place anti-gay discrimination over national security."

Deroy Murdock, a columnist with the Scripps Howard News Service, agreed.:

"Whatever one thinks of homosexuality, Americans should agree -- especially now -- that the Pentagon ought to stay focused on first things, such as preventing America's wily enemies from converting more skyscrapers into high-rise crematoria," Murdock said.

"Knowing the rarity of U.S. Arabic linguists with security clearance, do we invite these fired linguists to re-enter the military or forego their talents, even if doing so means that al-Qaeda can succeed in detonating a smallpox weapon or dirty bomb because we did not have the talent to translate information that could prevent such attacks?"
For More ...
Related Stories
U.S. Army Fires Significant Numbers of Gay Arabic Translators

Frank Kameny: Army Firing Gay Arabic Translators is Treason

Military Advocacy Group Honors LGBT World War II Veterans

Related Sites
Servicemembers Legal Defense Network