top2.gif - 6.71 K

bannerbot.gif - 8.68 K

McKinney Claims Ignorance Matthew Shepard Was Gay

Billy Jack's Killer, Mullins, Pleads Guilty to Capital Murder

Mullins to Avoid Chair?—McKinney Saying Not a Hate Crime?

Compiled By GayToday

shepelecchair2.jpg - 9.26 K Washington, D.C.--When John Aravosis of Wired Strategies here heard that Matthew Shepard's alleged killer, Aaron McKinney was saying he hadn't known Matthew was gay, he deadpanned his response: "Yeah, right."

"In an apparent effort to deny the fact that Shepard's death was a violent anti-gay hate crime," Aravosis theorized, "Aaron McKinney is now trying to claim he didn't even know Matt was gay."

McKinney, the Washington strategist points out, seems to be contradicting earlier statements he reportedly made. The Rocky Mountain News (April 7) said of him, for example:

"McKinney confessed to sheriff's Detective Sgt. Rob DeBree in an Oct. 9 interview that he had lured Shepard out of the bar, robbed him and repeatedly hit him. McKinney said he knew Shepard was homosexual, and that the University of Wyoming student never made any advances to him, according to testimony at McKinney's preliminary hearing last fall.

" 'Guess what? We're not gay. You're going to get jacked,' DeBree testified, relating what McKinney said he told Shepard seconds before landing the first blow with a stolen .357-caliber pistol."

In a separate article, the Rocky Mountain News told:

"When Aaron McKinney learned that Matthew Shepard was gay, he 'flipped out' and beat the college student with a gun, two letters attributed to the murder suspect reveal. Shepard 'said he was gay and wanted a piece of me,' according to one letter, both of which were obtained by News4 reporter Rick Sallinger from an attorney in the case.

"'Being a verry (sic) drunk homofobick (sic) I flipped out and began to pistol whip the f-- with my gun,' said the letter, written to a cellmate's wife."

Reports also circulated nationally in October, 1998 stating that McKinney and Russell Henderson had lured Matthew Shepard from a campus bar by telling him they were gay and that they wanted to get to know him better.

Bill McKinney, the defendant's father and Kristen Price '(one of the two girlfriend/accomplices)' were reported by the Denver Post (October 11, 1998) as saying that "McKinney, 22, was embarrassed that Shepard made two passes at him in front of his friends."

Controversy is now heard as to the wisdom of the surprise legal strategy that has been adopted by Aaron McKinney's lawyer, namely, that the defendant had no knowledge of Matthew's openly-espoused sexual self-definition.
Murderer Pleads Guilty in Alabama's Billy Jack Gaither Case

Coosa County Circuit Court , Alabama--Billy Jack Gaither's 25-year-old confessed murderer, Steven Eric Mullins, pleaded guilty here to the capital murder of the quiet-mannered 39-year-old Alabama gay man.

Mullins entered his plea in the presence of the parents of the murdered man.

Still facing trial is Charles Monroe Butler, 21. The two men were said to have known their victim and had reportedly planned his murder well in advance.

A reservoir outside Sylacauga, Alabama served as the spot where Billy Jack Gaither was first beaten, the killers stuffing his body into the trunk of his car. Then they purposely acquired matches, kerosene, and two old tires.

Related Stories from the GayToday Archive:
GayToday Hate Crimes Series

Matthew Shepard's Murder: Gay Hate Crime of the Century

Billy Jack's Killer: "God Told Me to Confess!"

Beheading: A Grisly Murder in Virginia

Related Sites:
Wired Strategies

GayToday does not endorse related sites.

Driving to an isolated spot, they again beat their victim, this time with an ax handle, lighting the old tires with the kerosene, and placing Gaither's body atop to burn. Gaither was found the following day.

In exchange for the murderers' guilty pleas, prosecutors had said last March that they would recommend a sentence of life without parole for the accused men rather than death in Alabama's electric chair.

``I kidnapped Mr. Gaither, forced him into the car and killed him intentionally,'' Mullins confessed to the court.

bannerbot.gif - 8.68 K
© 1997-99 BEI

Visit Badpuppy.com