top2.gif - 6.71 K

watermark3.gif - 15.76 K

Boy Scout Leader's Use of Gay Photo Target Draws Fire

Bulls-Eye News Picture of Gay Eagle Scout is Shredded

Rhode Island's Camp Yawgood Hosts Rifle Controversy

By Paul Barwick

Rockville, Rhode Island--He lifted the rifle to his shoulder and pulled the trigger. Several yards away a newspaper photo of Eagle Scout James Dale shredded. Those watching nodded. They understood the message.

According to newspaper reports the leader then offered the youngsters the rifle and encouraged them, too, to take a shot at the photo of the gay man.

These events took place in early August on the rifle range of one of the nation's largest and most respected Boy Scout camps, Rhode Island's Camp Yawgoog. The rifleman was a Boy Scout Troop leader.
jdaleshoot.jpg - 8.49 K
Eagle Scout James Dale has once again come under attack from the Boy Scouts ... this time a Rhode Island Scout leader used his photo for target practice at a Scout camp.

The Scouts subsequently kicked the gun slinging troop leader out of the camp, not for giving the impression that it was OK to use gays as targets, but because, they said, he had violated a National Rifle Association rule that prohibits using a target shaped to resemble a human.

The Scouts have not apologized. Neither have they indicated that they will say anything to the youths to indicate such violence is not condoned. Camp Yawgoog officials had not returned phone calls by press time.

James Dale was "upset and horrified" when he learned that Boy Scouts had been using his picture as a rifle range target according to his friend and attorney Lambda Legal Defense Fund's Evan Wolfson.

Wolfson, who as part of a nine year battle had successfully argued Dale's case to the New Jersey Supreme Court, said that he himself was "Outraged."

ewolfson.jpg - 5.16 K
Evan Wolfson
He went on to say "This highlights the connection... over and over again organizations stigmatize gays, and this behavior leads to violence." He said that the message of intolerance does get turned into violence. "We've seen that again and again, It is particularly sad to see this now in the Boy Scouts."

"This (use of photos) is a tactic seen in organized hate groups and the anti-government movement" Joe Roy, Intelligence Director of the Southern Poverty Law Center pointed out to this writer.

He explained that such target practice is a method used by hate groups to demean and dehumanize their enemies. "So that you can do things that you normally wouldn't to another person. You have made them sub-human, like Furrow in Los Angeles, shooting children."

Buford O.Furrow Jr., who has reportedly admitted to shooting several people, including small children, in and near a Jewish day care center described the people he shot, all whom he targeted because they were Jewish or non-white, as "mud people".

According to police reports Furrow had planned to attack a gay bar in San Francisco after the Los Angeles shootings, but instead abandoned those plans and turned himself in to FBI agents in Nevada.

Roy would have liked to check if the rifle toting Scoutmaster was known to have been a member of one of the fringe groups that the SPLC monitors, but Boy Scout officials have not released the man's name. He commented that the incident demonstrated "incredibly poor judgment at best."

David Elliot, communications director for the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force told Gay Today:

"The Boy Scouts' oath says a Scout must be 'morally straight.' Scout law requires the young men to be 'clean in thought, word and deed.' I see nothing moral nor clean about using a picture of someone for target practice.

"Teaching this kind of hate and intolerance is the antithesis of what scouting is all about. The Scouts also pride themselves on their belief in God. But I know of no religious denomination that teaches kids to use a human face as target practice.

"We live in a time when, sadly, hate crimes are on the rise against people who are viewed as different. Attacks on synagogues, abortion clinics, or gay bars are symptoms of the same epidemic of hate. The Boy Scouts of America should treat these symptoms by teaching that our differences and our diversity make America richer, not poorer."

The target incident was just one of a series of events which rocked the camp over a period of days, one of which resulted in the Boy Scouts of America, for the first time in their history, terminating and then reinstating an openly gay camp employee, an Eagle Scout.

That change of heart came after 90 staff members and fellow scouts went on a supportive sit-down strike, causing closure of the camp for the first time in its 84 year history, and after the young scout filed a complaint under Rhode Island's strict anti-discrimination laws.

Related Stories from the GayToday Archive:
Boy Scouts Ban Overturned by New Jersey Supreme Court

Unitarian Universalist Church Blasts Back at the Boy Scouts of America

Boy Scouts Anti-Gay Ruling in California Critqued

Related Sites:
Scouting for All

Lambda Legal Defense & Education Network

Southern Poverty Law Center

GayToday does not endorse related sites.

The 16-year-old, who has asked not to be identified in the media, is president of his school's Gay/Straight Alliance and is an honor student. He is now an openly gay Eagle Scout, free to work at Camp Yawgoog. To the best of this writer's knowledge he is the only officially out gay acknowledged and accepted by the national leadership of The Boy Scouts of America.

bannerbot.gif - 8.68 K
© 1997-99 BEI

Visit Badpuppy.com