top2.gif - 6.71 K

Badpuppy.com

lettertop.gif - 16.22 K Pen Points
Letters to
Gay Today


STAR Pioneers Blast HRC Transphobia

nicholsrivera.jpg - 11.15 K GayToday's Jack Nichols with transgender activist Sylvia Rivera This is to inform the Human Rights Campaign (hrc) after much debate and soul-searching and a number of votes the membership of Street Transgender Action Revolutionaries hereby decline your endorsement of the Amanda Milan actions scheduled here in New York.

You are a separatist organization devoted to money and power that has insulted STAR and the transgender community through your ignorance, arrogance and transphobia. This decision and letter will go out to the public throughout this country and the world.

We in no way find your message to us acceptable - the message was hardly an apology. You seemed to feel that you had to tread carefully with the people of color organizations that you did write with the kind of wording that viewed them - who are our supporters - as co-equals.

It seems to us that your mistrust of STAR, your excuse being that you had not heard of us, was uncalled for. People in high places such as yourselves lack trans history 101. Street Transgender Action Revolutionaries was the first political trans organization in New York City and possibly the United States. We were formed in 1971 with myself and the late Marsha P. Johnson who saw the need to stress transgender politics because of the lack of interest in the mainstream gay community in transgender rights.

STAR membership feels the disrespect that you showed our organization is beyond belief. The fact that you may have faced miseducation your entire privileged lives about the existence of trans people and trans rights is no excuse. You aspire to a position of leadership in this community, and therefore you have to learn about all of the community, not just a part of it.

Of course you might have known us by our co-organizers and sponsors of the Amanda Milan demonstrations, which include AVP, MCC New York, Amnesty International and the National Organization of Women as well as grassroots organizations from every part of society in New York, across the country and in Europe and South America. No other sponsor told us they had to check up on us before endorsing--the urgency of justice was enough.

It seems by your last letter, which puts gender rights in second place to sexual orientation and your actions in Maryland passing a bill that does not include gender identity that the hrc is a separatist organization that is only concerned with sexual orientation and nothing with gender identity. How much more bigoted can a large organization that preaches equality for be, making such a statement. You failed to tell the community that one of the only reasons that you decided to change your mission statement was due to the fact that STAR sponsored an e-mail campaign to get you to change your position on Amanda.

Related Stories from the GayToday Archive:
Street Transgender Action Revolutionaries Demand Justice

Transsexual Amanda Milan, 25, Murdered in Manhattan

1 Dead, Six Wounded in a Roanoke, Virginia Gay Bar

Baptist Princess, Sister Taffy, Interviews Jack Nichols

Related Sites:
National Transgendered Advocacy Coalition

Out to Change

Sister Taffy's Friends of Baby Jesus
GayToday does not endorse related sites.

We are not surprised that we had to turn to public pressure to change your position, since you are after all the same organization that endorsed Al D'Amato in the New York Senate election of 1998. If you can endorse Al D'Amato, you must find the trans community and our desire for justice for Amanda to be extremely distasteful.

Have you given any thought to all the lives that have been taken in the past and in the future due to the lack of your interest in the trans community. Not being able to obtain jobs, education and shelter condemns the youth in our community to prostitution, drug abuse and vulnerability to anti-trans violence. How many more must die? Maybe if we had our rights there would be fewer attacks--perhaps this logic escapes you.

You say that you will assist the trans community as we search for our rights but at the same time you back up the anti-trans bigotry of "congressmen" as you deny us our place in ENDA, lobby against us behind the backs of our democratic organizations and in local ENDA bills such as the one that you supported in Maryland. That is bigotry in itself.

You state that Congress is uneducated on trans issues. But such a large, prominent and wealthy organization such as yours has always had the responsibility to bring trans issues as a co-equal to sexual orientation to Congress.

To us your organization is defined just by money, the money that separatists in the gay community have gained by saying they are not us and are willing to abandon us for the so-called security that they think they gain by adhering to the transphobic rules that straight society lays down for those who wish auxiliary status, the "we are just like you" crowd.

It seems like you think you can buy your way in by forgetting a part of who you are You think you will be able to defend yourselves by forgetting about the street queens who started the Stonewall Riots? You are taking the entire community down a path of self-destruction by destroying our hopes and dreams first. You wend your way among shadows of hatred and guilt, not the strong, open lives that gay people are supposed to be proud of. You cannot erase gender issues from the "gay community," especially not by forgetting us and defining yourselves against us. Trans culture has always helped define gay lives

For us to condone your separation of trans people from the gay community would be to condone the hatred that is the hatred that led to the death of Amanda Milan.

You seem to want to leave your sisters and brothers to feed on nothing, to be the dregs that it is okay for everyone to hate and dispense with. You are killing us.

The hrc is a hateful organization that will dissolve in the face of the efforts of all of the trans community to have the full lives that we deserve, not to live without employment, housing, education. It is we with our allies that will make the world that everyone would have were it not for those such as yourselves who. make a show out of justice, liberty and community.

Hopefully in the future you or perhaps only some of you change your attitudes toward the trans community we may be able to work together. One of our initial plans after we received the dried-up gristle that you threw us with your endorsement was to accept it and to ask to have you sponsor a trans conference of all trans organizations in the United States to see how we could all work together. We will, of course, fight for our rights with or without you.

cc: GayToday

Sylvia Rivera
E-mail: stactionrevs@onebox.com


Responding to the
Roanoke Bar Shooting Tragedy

For those of you who are local here in Roanoke, we wanted to remind you of today's tour of the Out to Change Center. The center is located at 17 Highland Avenue SW in Roanoke, near the corner of Jefferson & 1st.

Out to Change is an organization formed by members of Roanoke7, Inc and members of the Danny Overstreet family to create a loving place of affirmation for all people. The center will consist of an established art gallery, a vintage store and a social club.
roanoke7a.jpg - 8.92 K Roanoke 7 murder victim Danny Overstreet

Inspirations Art Gallery will for a time be jointlu managed by Out to Change & Healthy Maintenance, Inc, the current owners. After a transition period, it will become a project of Out to Change. The OTC Vintage Store was created by members of Roanoke7 who are selling off personal belongings to make this happen.

The Gallery Social Club is meant to be a place of music & entertainment, an alternative place for those who might enjoy a place to go, free from cigarette smoke & tobacco. We'll close rather early on weekends so those of you who want to go out afterwards will still have plenty of time to get where you're going. Smoking is permitted on the front porch where you'll find a great view of Mill Mountain and the Star.

We have been notified that Ted Koppel's ABC News Nightline will be here today between 1-5. Other media people could be here as well.

For those who were not able to access the site via the email link, you have our apology. We haven't had time to figure out the technical stuff yet, so busy getting ready!

You can go directly to our website at www.outtochange.org

You might have to cut and paste the address.

For those of you outside Roanoke, consider this an update on our efforts to create a beautiful place for the citizens of Roanoke to enjoy life, music, art, & culture. The center will open officially on Saturday, May 19th, timed to coinside with the start of the Roanold Edward Gay trial. We felt it was important to show this community that love overcomes evil and hate does not destroy, it can become the building block for a new future for those so tragically affected by it. This center is a place for all of us!

Looking forward to your visit or the prayers of those of you who cannot be here!

Sincerely,
Eddie Ratliff
Director


Baptist Princess, Sister Taffy

Thank you for bringing us the interview by Sister Taffy. With her funny Southern Baptist initiatives, I am reminded of a remark from Mel Brooks, the producer of the current Broadway blockbuster, "The Producers". When asked how he as a Jew approached the horrors done to his people during WWII, he replied, "The effective way to get back at them is through ridicule". It is appropriate to continue ridiculing the Southern Baptists in order to shed light on their unacceptable bigotry and how they choose to demonize our families of diversity through their "baby Jesus". sistertaffy3.jpg - 10.11 K Sister Taffy:
A Friend of Baby Jesus

Kindest regards
Charles Merrill


Sister Taffy Rules

A stroke of sheer genius. Is Sister Taffy going to get her own column on your site? There are bunches of us "homo-sexuals" who need her spiritual guidance. More like this please!!!

Great job guys!

Jack Reynolds,
Recovering Baptist




© 1997-2002 BEI