top2.gif - 6.71 K


www.cybersocket.com

Charges Dropped Against
18-Year Old Alleged Killer


Thomas Minch Remains
Viable Suspect, Officials Say


Police Retreat from Bad Case
to Return Another Day

By Jack Nichols

Washington, D.C.--For those seeking justice and immediate answers to questions surrounding the murder of gay Gallaudet University student Eric Franklin Plunckett, the latest development in the case, says newsman Scott Miller, is disturbing. Though he remains a viable suspect, Plunkett's 18-year-old alleged killer, Thomas Minch, has been released. eplunkett.jpg - 8.35 K Murdered student Eric Plunckett

After the second degree murder charges were dropped less than 24 hours following Minch's arrest, U.S. marshals escorted him out of the court through a back door, helping him avoid both the media and his fellow Gallaudet students. The Washington Post considered this move “a departure from the usual manner of allowing defendants to turn from the bench and leave through the open court.”

The detectives who arrested Minch had acted too hastily, according to top-level police officials. This does not mean that they were necessarily wrong, according to Washington's Executive Assistant Police Chief, Terrance W. Gainer, who believes his subordinates had made what he called “a reasonable judgment.”

Gainer, who offered no apology to Minch, said instead that his men, rather than trying to “defend a bad case” would instead “retreat and come back another day.” This means, he assured reporters, that Minch could be charged again.

Police believe that a struggle took place after a heated disagreement and that Eric Plunkett had been struck on the head and neck with a chair. The second degree murder charge is justified they say, because the crime was not premeditated.

Scott Miller, distressed by the implications of the dismissed charge, expressed the views of others, including Gallaudet students who are feeling a similar discomfort. He said:

"I do not mean to imply that we need to jump to judgement on Minch, but this relative uncertainty does not give me confidence that the killer of Puckett will soon have to face punishment.

Related Stories from the GayToday Archive:

Deaf/ Gay Student Murdered at Gallaudet University

Fellow Student is Charged in the Killing of Eric Plunkett

1 Dead, Six Wounded in a Roanoke, Virginia Gay Bar

Related Sites:
Anti-Violence Project

GayToday does not endorse related sites.

“There are obviously too many holes at the moment to proceed with an arraignment. I hope this doesn't speak to the relative lack of evidence in this case.”



bannerbot.gif - 8.68 K
© 1997-2000 BEI