|
No Religious Vouchers! |
Compiled By GayToday
"This is a great early Christmas present for America's public schools and our constitutional principles," said Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United. "This means that taxpayer money will not be diverted from public schools to private religious schools." A coalition of education and civil liberties groups challenged the 5-year-old Cleveland voucher program in federal court in July 1999. Last year, U.S. District Court Judge Solomon Oliver ruled against the program, concluding that public funding of private religious education ran afoul of the First Amendment's separation of church and state. Today's 2-1 ruling upholds that decision.
The court added, "This scheme involves the grant of state aid directly and predominantly to the coffers of the private, religious schools, and it is unquestioned that these institutions incorporate religious concepts, motives, and themes into all facets of their educational planning. There is no neutral aid when that aid principally flows to religious institutions; nor is there truly 'private choice' when the available choices resulting from the program design are predominantly religious." The 6th Circuit's decision is the latest in a long line of setbacks for voucher advocates, who include U.S. Presidential candidate, George W. Bush and associated Republican hardliners. Last year, another federal appellate court struck down a voucher-like program in Maine. The State Supreme Courts of Vermont, Maine and Puerto Rico have also declared voucher programs unconstitutional. In addition, voucher supporters have been rebuffed repeatedly by voters. Last month, voters in Michigan and California overwhelmingly defeated voucher ballot initiatives. Despite massive spending by voucher advocates, both measures were defeated by better than 2-1 margins. No voucher referendum put before voters has ever passed. "Sooner or later, voucher proponents will have to realize that the law is not on their side -- and neither is public opinion," said Lynn. "Americans must never be forced to support private religious education, and the appellate court wisely supported that principle today." Ralph G. Neas, President of People For The American Way Foundation, agrees. "Today's ruling is a victory for the First Amendment and a victory for public education," he said, "Ohio lawmakers should now focus their energies on working to ensure that their state's public schools are the strongest they can possibly be." |